Used discs displayed in store

Why Buy Used Disc Golf Discs? The Real Advantages

Plenty of players treat used discs as the budget option: what you buy when new isn't in the budget. Price is part of it. But a used disc can also give you something a new disc can't, which is a flight that has already changed with play.

Here's what buying used actually gets you, and when a new disc is the better choice.

Illustration of a disc golf bag and three lightly worn discs on a wooden counter inside a disc golf shop.

1. They Usually Cost Less

A used copy of a disc is usually priced below a new copy of the same disc. That makes it easier to fill out a bag, replace a disc you lost, or carry a backup without paying full price for each one.

The exception is collectible discs: rare stamps, special runs, or discontinued molds. Those can sell for more used than they cost new, because the supply is limited.

2. A Beat-In Flight You Can't Buy New

This is the advantage that isn't about price.

As discs take hits from trees, rocks, and hard landings, they commonly become less stable: easier to turn at high speed, with less fade at the end. Players call this being beat in or seasoned. Base plastics generally season faster than premium plastics.

Plenty of players break in discs on purpose for exactly this reason. A seasoned copy of a stable disc can hold a straighter line or a turnover shot that a new copy won't give you yet. Buying used means someone else has already done the seasoning.

More wear isn't automatically better. A seasoned disc can give you the turnover you want, or turn more than you need. The advantage is finding a disc whose current flight suits a shot in your bag.

Our guide on when to retire or replace a disc explains how wear changes flight in more detail.

3. They Can Be Easier for Newer Players

Newer players usually generate less disc speed than experienced players. Stable discs thrown at lower speed often fade early and come up short.

A beat-in disc that has lost some of its stability can be easier to get a full flight out of at lower speeds. Combined with the lower price, that makes a well-chosen used disc a reasonable option for someone still building a bag. Our post on why understable discs are good for beginners explains the stability side of this.

"Well-chosen" is doing real work in that sentence. A heavily worn disc can be harder to learn with, not easier, if it turns more than you can control.

4. A Cheaper Way to Try a Mold

Curious about a disc your friend throws? Wondering if a different putter feels better in your hand? A used copy lets you find out without paying full price.

Keep in mind that a used copy may fly differently than a new copy of the same mold, because of wear. It tells you a lot about how the disc feels in your hand, and less about exactly how a fresh one would fly.

5. Discs That Are Out of Production

Manufacturers retire molds, plastic blends, and runs. Once a disc is out of production, the used market is often the main place left to find one. If you have a disc you rely on and it's been discontinued, buying used is often the most practical way to find a backup.

6. A Backup That Flies More Like Your Gamer

Lose a disc you've thrown for years and replace it with a new copy, and you may find the new one doesn't fly like the old one did. Your old disc had seasoned. The new one hasn't.

A used copy with similar wear and plastic may come closer to the flight you're used to than a brand-new one. It's not a guarantee, since two discs of the same mold don't always fly the same even when new, but it can shorten the time it takes to get back to a disc you trust. Our post on why two of the same disc fly differently covers why.

7. More Discs Stay in Play

A disc that no longer fits one player's bag can still be the right disc for someone else. Buying used keeps playable discs on the course instead of sitting in a closet.

What to Know Before Buying Used

Illustration of hands inspecting the rim of a used turquoise disc over a shop counter, with shelves of discs behind.

A few things are worth knowing before you pick one out.

  • The flight numbers may not describe it. Flight numbers are a guide to how a new disc is meant to fly. A used disc may turn more and fade less than its numbers suggest.
  • You don't know its full history. Heat, hard impacts, and repairs can all affect a disc in ways that are hard to see.
  • Damage can rule it out. A cracked disc, for example, is illegal for PDGA-sanctioned play and can keep getting worse with more impacts.
  • Consistency is harder. If you're building a set of discs that fly predictably next to each other, new copies give you an unworn starting point.

When to Buy New Instead

Illustration of three new disc golf discs displayed on a wooden shop counter, with a cream putter standing behind green and orange discs.

Used isn't always the better call. New makes more sense when:

  • You want to start with an unworn disc and learn how its flight changes as you play.
  • You want a disc that will stay stable for longer, such as a premium-plastic overstable disc for headwinds or forehand shots.
  • You want a putter with fresh plastic and don't want to guess at how a used one's grip has held up.
  • You can't find a used copy you're confident about.

Frequently Asked Questions

Illustration of a shop associate explaining the wear on a used turquoise disc to a customer at the counter.

Are used disc golf discs worth it?

They can be. A used disc in good shape usually costs less than a new copy, and a beat-in disc may already fly a line a new copy won't. The ones to skip are discs with real problems: cracks, warping, heavy rim damage, or heavy sanding and added coatings.

Are used discs good for beginners?

A well-chosen one can be. A beat-in disc that has lost some stability can be easier to get a full flight out of at lower throwing speeds. A heavily worn disc that turns too much can make learning harder, so look at how much wear it has, not just the price.

Do used discs fly differently than new ones?

Often, yes. Discs commonly become less stable as they wear, so a used disc may turn more and fade less than a new copy of the same mold. How much depends on the plastic, how long it was played, and what it hit along the way.

Are used discs legal in PDGA tournaments?

Being used doesn't make a disc illegal. Under PDGA Rule 813.01, wear from normal play is allowed, and so are moderate sanding to smooth wear and marking with dye or permanent marker. Cracks, holes, excessive sanding, added material like paint, and other changes to a disc's original flight characteristics can make a disc illegal. If you're unsure about a specific disc, ask the tournament director.

Should I buy a used disc or a new one?

It depends on what you want the disc to do. If you want an unworn disc to learn and season yourself, buy new. If you want a seasoned flight, a lower price, or a disc that's out of production, used is worth a look.

Buy or Sell Used Discs In Store

Looking for your next disc? Visit True North Disc Golf to browse our used selection, check the wear, and feel the plastic before you buy.

Have discs you no longer throw? Bring them in if you're interested in selling.

Visit us at 49 Charlotte St, Brantford, Ontario, to buy or sell used discs. Our used selection is available in store only.

Looking to buy new discs? Check out our wide selection Disc Golf Discs

Back to blog